The Furor Over FUOrs

FU Orionis and its associated nebula. Image credit: ESO
In 1937, an ordinary 16th magnitude star in the constellation Orion began to brighten steadily. Thinking it was a nova, astronomers were astounded when the star just kept getting brighter and brighter over the course of a year. Most novae burst forth suddenly and then begin to fade within weeks. But this star, now glowing at 9th magnitude, refused to fade. Adding to the puzzle, astronomers could see there was a gaseous nebula nearby shining from the reflected light of this mysterious star, now named FU Orionis. What was this new kind of star?

FU Ori has remained in this high state, around 10th magnitude ever since. This was a from of stellar variability never seen before. Since there were no other examples of this kind of variable star astronomers were forced to learn what they could from the only known example, or wait for another event to provide more clues.

Finally, more than 30 years later, FU Ori-like behavior appeared again in 1970 when the star now known as V1057 Cyg increased in brightness by 5.5 magnitudes over 390 days. Then in 1974, a 3rd example was discovered when V1515 Cyg rose from 17th magnitude to 12th magnitude over an interval lasting years. Astronomers began piecing the puzzle together from these clues.

FU Orionis stars are pre-main sequence stars in the early stages of stellar development. They have only just formed from clouds of dust and gas in interstellar space, which occur in active star- forming regions. They are all associated with reflection nebulae, which become visible as the star brightens.

This artist's concept shows a young stellar object 
and the whirling accretion disk surrounding it.  
NASA/JPL-Caltech
 
Astronomers are interested in these systems because FUOrs may provide us with clues to the early history of stars and the formation of planetary systems. At this early stage of evolution, a YSO is surrounded by an accretion disk, and matter is falling onto the outer regions of the disk from the surrounding interstellar cloud. Thermal instabilities, most likely in the inner portions of the accretion disk, initiate an outburst and the young star increases its luminosity. Our Sun probably went through similar events as it was developing.

One of the major challenges in studying FU Orionis stars is the relatively small number of known examples. Although approximately 20 FU Orionis candidates have been identiļ¬ed, only a handful of these stars have been observed to rise from their pre-outburst state to their eruptive state.

Now, in the last year, several new FUOrs have been discovered. In November 2009, two newly discovered objects were announced in Central Bureau Electronic Telegrams (CBET) #2033. Patrick Wils, John Greaves and the Catalina Real-time Transient Survey (CRTS) collaboration had discovered them in CRTS images.

The first of these objects appears to coincide with the infrared source IRAS 06068-0641.  Discovered by the CRTS on Nov. 10, it had been continuously brightening from at least early 2005 (when it was mag 14.8 on unfiltered CCD images) to its present mag 12.6. A faint cometary reflection nebula was visible to the east.  A spectrum taken with the SMARTS 1.5-m telescope at Cerro Tololo, on Nov. 17, confirmed it to be a young stellar object.  The object lies inside a dark nebula to the south of the Monocerotis R2 association, and is likely related to it.  


Also inside this dark nebula, a second object, coincident with IRAS 06068-0643, had been varying between mag 15 and 20 over the past few years, reminiscent of UX-Ori-type objects with very deep fades.  This second object is also associated with a variable cometary reflection nebula, extending to the north.  The spectrum of this object also shows H_alpha and the strong Ca II infrared triplet in emission. 

Light curves, spectra and images can be found here.

In August 2010, two new eruptive, pre-main sequence stars were discovered in Cygnus.  The first object was an outburst of the star HBC 722. The object was reported to have risen by 3.3 magnitudes from May 13 to August 16, 2010. Spectroscopy reported by U. Munari et al in ATel #2808, Aug 23, 2010 support this object's classification as an FU Ori star. Munari and his team reported the object at 14.04V on Aug 21, 2010.

The second object, coincident with the infrared source IRAS 20496+4354, was discovered by K. Itagaki (Yamagata, Japan) on August 23, 2010 and reported in CBET 2426.  The object appears very faint (magnitude 20) in a DSS image taken in 1990.  Subsequent spectroscopy and photometry of this object by U. Munari showed that this object also has the characteristics of an FU Ori star. Munari reported the object at 14.91V on August 26, 2010. 

 
Both these objects are now the subjects of an AAVSO observing campaign announced October 1, 2010 in AAVSO Alert Notice 425
Dr. Colin Aspin (U. Hawai'i) has requested the help of AAVSO observers in performing long-term photometric monitoring of these two new YSOs in Cygnus. AAVSO observations will be used to help calibrate optical and near-infrared spectroscopy to be obtained during the next year. 
Since these stars are newly discovered, very little is known about their behavior. Their classification as FU Ori variables is based on spectroscopy by U. Munari et al. Establishing a good light curve and maintaining it, over the next several years, will be crucial to understanding these stars. This kind of long-term monitoring is one of the things at which amateur astronomers excel.

November 10, 2010, results presenting rare pre and post outburst observations from the 
Palomar Transient Factory (PTF) show that HBS722 is a bona fide FU Ori type star that was a classical T-Tauri star before eruption, providing strong evidence that FU Orionis eruptions represent periods of enhanced disk accretion and outflow, likely triggered by instabilities in the accretion disk. 
Another paper, released the next day, also based on observations from the PTF, shows IRAS 20496+4354 brightened by more than 5 magnitudes, reaching 13.5R in September 2010. Near-infrared spectra appear quite similar to a spectrum of McNeil's Nebula/V1647 Ori, a FUOr which has undergone several brightenings in recent decades.


So after a very slow start, discoveries of new YSOs and our understanding of the dusty disk environments around them are starting to heat up. With new tools and new examples to study we are peering into the the early stages of stellar and planetary formation and finding some of our models have been pretty close to the truth. We expect to find more and similar objects as new all-sky surveys begin to cover the sky, but these objects will still be relatively rare and therefore interesting, because this period in a star's evolution is short-lived and only takes place in the active star forming regions of galaxies.


Images of HBC722 and  IRAS 20496+4354 from  
Discovery of possible FU-Ori and UX-Ori type objects
Wils, P., Greaves, J. and the CRTS collaboration, Nov 18th 2009.
http://crts.caltech.edu/CSS091110.html

4 comments:

Sakib said...

I just found out about HBC 722 and the other outbursting protostar a couple of days ago and I was shocked to see the discovery mentioned on this blog! I absolutely love FUors, this might be my favourite post so far! V1515 Cygni is possibly my favourite FUor, it can be seen in this image: http://www.capella-observatory.com/ImageHTMLs/DiffuseNebula/NGC6914.htm

Its interesting that there are half a dozen FUors in Cygnus, many of them might be localised to one or two spiral arms.

There is another possible FUor in Monoceros near the obscure nebula LBN 1022. Last year, an amateur called Jim Thommes photographed this region and his image showed a new nebula that is nearly invisible on the DSS image. His image is here: http://jthommes.com/Astro/LBN1022.htm

I can't wait to find out more about the new Cygnus discoveries next year!

Mike Simonsen said...

Thanks, Sakib. It shouldn't come as a surprise, really. Simostronomy is all about variable stars and stellar evolution.
Mike

Sakib said...

The surprise comes from how soon this discovery was posted! There is now a reflection nebula around HBC 722 and there is a great image by Joseph Brimacombe: http://www.flickr.com/photos/43846774@N02/4968162388/

Also both of the nebulae associated with the two possible FUors in Monoceros can be seen in the top right corner of this image by Russell Croman from 2007: http://www.rc-astro.com/photo/id1178_big.html

However the nebula associated with IRAS 06068-643 isn't visible in this image by Rob Gendler from the beginning of this year: http://www.robgendlerastropics.com/NGC2170AUM.html

I presume the star has got fainter since 2007 and doesn't illuminate the dust around it. I wonder if it would be visible in an image taken at the beginning of next year.

Cam said...

I had no idea so many FUors had been discovered this past year!

I am doing my thesis on TTS in the ONC and stumbled across your blog hunting down some background information and am very glad I did! Gives me hope I may find myself a FUor before this year is out :-)

Exciting stuff, I can't wait for some new data to be published so I can do some more searching!